I Live in NYC But Hate Flats—Here's What I Wear Instead
As an L.A. transplant who has only been living in NYC for roughly three years, I can tell you that one of the first things I learned about dressing for city life upon moving here was that the name of the game is comfort. Sounds simple enough, until I tell you that I hate flats—the footwear choice of commuters everywhere.
I don’t know why, but I’ve never been particularly into them. Sure, I might wear loafers or flat mules here and there if I feel like the pair is really worth an exception, but in general, I find flats to be neither comfortable nor aesthetically appealing. Plus, at 5’2”, I’m also always game for a little extra height, so I’ve come up with a list of worthy alternatives to wear instead. To see, read about, and, of course, shop the five comfortable shoe styles I wear instead of flats, just keep scrolling.
1. Mules
Remember when mules were just a trend? Now, I wonder what I’d do without them. From closed-toe styles to sandals, there’s a mule for everyone—and every outfit. Plus, there are so many comfortable options.
Shop mules:
2. Boots
All I can say about ankle boots is that I really, really love them. So much so that I own more pairs than I’m willing to admit and have a variety of styles for every season—even summer. Since I’m on the more petite side, I always opt for pairs that have even a one- or two-inch heel for a little extra height that’s still comfortable and easy to walk in all day.
Shop boots:
3. Kitten Heels
Kitten heels are those perfect shoes between flats and heels. They're comfortable, they pair well with both long and short hemlines, and they allow you to look put-together without feeling like you’re over- or underdressed.
Shop kitten heels:
4. Sneakers
Gym days aside, I always prefer sneakers to flats. First, they’re much better for your feet and even feel more comfortable. Next, the sneakers I wear tend to have a little height, which always helps. Last, they just feel like they’re giving your outfit a cool factor rather than simply blending in.
Shop sneakers:
5. Block-Heel Sandals
The second summer hits, I live in block-heel sandals. They allow me to feel taller without feeling like I’m wearing heels and are available in so many colors, styles, and heel heights. Because of the way pressure gets distributed over a wide surface on the bottom, they are comfortable.
This story was published at an earlier date and has been recently updated.
Since starting as an intern back in 2013, Nicole Akhtarzad Eshaghpour has held several roles here at Who What Wear, and she is currently Editor-at-Large. Upon joining, she was a senior about to graduate from business school at USC. Fast-forward to 2025, and she's moved to NYC from her hometown of Beverly Hills and spends her workdays a little differently from when she was just starting out. Currently, she focuses on a weekly mélange of shopping content and her Trust Me—Buy This newsletter. As far as her personal style goes, she's largely drawn to neutral, classic pieces but will always make an exception for something colorful or bejeweled as long as it's deemed worthy enough. After all, the only thing she loves more than a party is dressing up for one. On her downtime, she can usually be found at home eating something delicious and trying to force her husband to watch Summer House.
-
On the Streets of NY, It Girls With Expensive Taste Know to Never Wear Skinny Jeans With This Outfit
Swap in either of these denim styles instead.
-
My Most Fashionable Friends Live in NYC—They'll Love These 30 Wildly Chic Zara Finds
Cool new staples.
-
In SoHo, These Three Fashion Items Are Considered Every Fashion Person's Holy Grails
Worn separately or together.
-
Parisians and New Yorkers Are Stylish, Period—Here's What They'd Buy From the Nordstrom Half-Yearly Sale
Elevated basics, cool shoes, and so much more.
-
Downtown's Out—Uptown's In: Come Shopping With Me at Kallmeyer, Khaite, and Toteme
Hey, Upper East Siders.
-
This Stylish New Yorker Has Has Impeccable Taste—35 Chic Spring Picks That Have Her Attention
The dresses alone are gems.
-
I Have Proof—These Are the Shoes New Yorkers Always Wear With Trench Coats
It's NYC's spring uniform.
-
5 Activewear Trends I Spot in Every Pilates Studio in Manhattan
What NYC fashion people are wearing to work out.