What to Buy for Fall If You Don't Want to Regret It Next Year (or the Year After)

If your shopping goal for the coming season is to spend smartly and buy things you won't want to discard after a few months, then you're in the right place. As a notoriously safe-playing and risk-averse shopper, I’ve come to know what items are worth spending on and what will feel dated, or worse, not hold up well in the near future. Luckily, when it comes to fall fashion, luxe basics are the cornerstones of a chic and cool wardrobe anyway, so it’s easy to spend wisely while still buying pieces you really love and are excited to wear. Below, I’m highlighting seven such categories. From outerwear essentials to knits, boots, bags, and more, these are the pieces you’ll not only love this cold-weather season but can enjoy for years and years to come. Simply keep scrolling to get shopping, and take in some outfit inspo for each piece along the way.
Simple sweaters
I cannot think of a category where the phrase "buy cheap, buy twice" is more applicable than knitwear. I've learned the hard way that not all sweaters are created equal, and it's better to invest in a just a couple at higher price points than many cheaper ones that won't make it past the current season. Of course, be sure to care for them properly too.
Classic outerwear
Coats and jackets are my biggest shopping vice, and I like to think it's excusable to hoard them because, if you buy classic ones, they truly never go out of style. At most, you'll put them on the back burner for a year or two, but I've learned that they always come back.
Everyday boots
Statement-making boots and heeled options are nice and all, but if you want bang for your buck, splurge on a pair you'll use the most frequently. For me, that's the everyday boot. It can be any material, any style, even have a low heel, but it has to be something comfortable, neutral, and easy to pair with everything.
Polished pants
Perhaps it's because I'm in my trouser era, but I truly think that good pants are not only the cornerstone of a polished outfit, but they can be the basis of your whole look. Find a good pair of pants, and getting dressed feels almost too easy. No matter what you style with them, you'll always look put-together in trousers.
Luxe totes
Whether or not they're "trending," sometimes you just need a big bag to carry around all your stuff, and when you do, it's nice to have an option you love. A bag can make or break an outfit, and the below are sure to make it every time.
Layering tops
Fall weather can be quite variable, which often means that dressing in layers is not only recommended but necessary. Versatile, layerable tops will make that an easy feat. Plus, you can likely use them in other seasons, too.
Sleek flats
For the days and outfits where boots just don't look right and sneakers won't do, a sleep pair of flats will be your saving grace. Luckily, this season, the options are endless. Whether you're partial to a classic ballet, loafer, mule, or all three, there's no shortage of pairs you'll love and want to wear on repeat.
Since starting as an intern back in 2013, Nicole Akhtarzad Eshaghpour has held several roles here at Who What Wear, and she is currently Editor-at-Large. Upon joining, she was a senior about to graduate from business school at USC. Fast-forward to 2025, and she's moved to NYC from her hometown of Beverly Hills and spends her workdays a little differently from when she was just starting out. Currently, she focuses on a weekly mélange of shopping content and her Trust Me—Buy This newsletter. As far as her personal style goes, she's largely drawn to neutral, classic pieces but will always make an exception for something colorful or bejeweled as long as it's deemed worthy enough. After all, the only thing she loves more than a party is dressing up for one. On her downtime, she can usually be found at home eating something delicious and trying to force her husband to watch Summer House.
-
Low Budget, High Taste: 28 Under-$500 Items I’d Buy to Look On-Trend This Fall
Your must-have items lie ahead.
-
A First-of-Its-Kind Collaboration: Introducing New Balance x TAG Heuer
"It's a true partnership—something that we've been building over time together."
-
10 Trends Set to Define Spring 2026 Fashion
Explore our deep dive into the top trends from the runways.
-
Elsa Hosk is My Ultimate Fall Style Muse—7 Trends I'm Stealing From Her
Plus, where I'm buying them.
-
My Mom Is in Her 50s and Asked Me for Fashion Advice—8 Chic Nordstrom Outfits I Put Together for Her Under $425
Outdated prints and "ugly" shoes included.
-
Sophisticated Women in Paris, New York, and London Will Be Wearing These Luxury Items All Winter
Only speaking facts.
-
If I Had an Amex Black Card, These Are the Jaw-Dropping Fashion Items I Would Buy for Fall
You deserve to splurge.
-
If You Want an Elegant-Looking Fall Wardrobe, These 35 Nordstrom Sale Finds Belong in Your Cart
Up to 50% off.