Editor Instincts Activated: We're Grabbing These 18 Fall Pieces Before Everyone Else Does

As the temperature starts to dip and the crisp promise of fall settles in, my fashion-editor instincts kick into high gear. There’s something about the start of a new season that sparks a certain kind of sartorial urgency—the kind that has me mentally (and digitally) bookmarking every coat, boot, and layering piece that catches my eye. Naturally, given the scope of my job, I know I'm not alone: All of our editors are feverishly getting their fall shopping wish lists together, and honestly, the things on our buy list have never looked better.

In the spirit of stylish curiosity and team inspiration, I reached out to a few of the incredibly chic people on the Who What Wear team to find out exactly what they're buying, saving, and trying this season. From Toteme sock boots to indie-label trench coats and cashmere sweaters that the internet swears are dupes for The Row's, there's something for everyone (and every price point!) on this list.

Keep scrolling to see and shop the 18 fall pieces we're eyeing before everyone else does.

Shop Anna's Picks

"COS is behind some of my most-worn outerwear, and I can already tell that this directional trench coat will be my new go-to for fall. The retro car-coat shape and contrasting collar make it look especially premium."

"Flat sock boots appeared on the fall runways at Fforme, Alberta Ferretti, and TWP, taking them from 'outdated' to very right-now. I'm looking to invest in this Toteme pair to wear with denim, trousers, and maxi skirts."

Shop Bobby's Picks

"Zara's leather and suede jackets are always crowd-pleasers. I know this funnel-neck style will be a favorite. Plus, it's under $180!"

"Khaki jeans are the moment. The $98 pair from Levi's keeps selling out, so get them while you can!"

"I feel very passionate about short-sleeve knits right now. Picture this gorgeous Anine Bing style (it's wildly soft, FYI) with a leather skirt and boots."

Shop Nikki's Picks

"Ever since I saw the argyle knitwear in Khaite's F/W 25 show, I haven't been able to shake the idea of purchasing something similar. I love this iteration from Massimo Dutti because the pattern nails the trend, yet the neutral color palette lends an understated vibe—perfect for my minimalist style."

"Lately, it seems like every It girl is sporting Kallmeyer's Eloise minidress. While I wish I could pay the designer price, this elevated alt from Reformation will help me achieve the look."

Shop Audry's Picks

"The fact that I don't already own a trench coat is beyond me, especially considering that I tend to gravitate toward minimalist, chic outerwear. I've been particularly loving the options from Peachy Den and Rue Sophie. One styling trend I've been seeing a lot of lately that feels new for fall 2025 is pairing trench coats with capris."

Shop Josephine's Picks

"Ballet flats aren’t going anywhere this fall, but if you're looking for an autumn-friendlier look, try these brown suede ones from Madewell."

"Coach’s Gramercy Tote bag ties in my two favorite bag trends of the season: winged tote and a suede finish."

Shop Judith's Picks

"Nothing marks the start of fall like the reemergence of a jacket into my daily outfit rotation. The first style I'm buying? A funnel-neck silhouette with a sporty sensibility. This one from Massimo Dutti is at the top of my cart."

"I'm obsessed with all the gorgeous lace-trimmed pieces for fall. This Zara one is perfect to layer under a sweater and over my jeans."

Shop Allyson's Picks

"Whenever I purchase something from Dôen, I know I'll be hanging on to it for years, so I have no regrets splurging on something like this classic cardigan."

"This is the perfect summer-to-fall minidress. And at 5'4", I appreciate the abbreviated length."

Shop Ana's Picks

"I've seen this COS chunky cashmere knit over and over on TikTok, mostly because creators swear it's a dupe for a similar sweater from The Row. After massively purging my closet this summer, I'm itching to add a forever piece to my cold-weather wardrobe, and this just might live up to the hype."

"Although I'm often partial to wide-leg flowy pants in lieu of gathered joggers, like the above pants, I've been seeing genie-style balloon pants across my feed and, of course, at Alaïa shows. Given that this pair is so cheap, might as well try them out."

"Gone are the days of mini sunglasses. I've been loving the style of oversize, aviator frames à la Phoebe Philo. Plus, Heaven Mayhem is one of my favorite accessories brands, and this pair does the trick for a fair price."

"This fall, I want all of my handbags to look like they're plucked straight from my grandma's archive—that is to say, simple, understated, and vintage feeling. This east-west clutch from Verafied has a top-handle strap and is a modern, sleek take on a vintage-feeling clasp frame bag. I'm obsessed."