While the internet continues to speculate about rumored tension between Justin and Hailey Bieber, the beauty mogul has been living her best life in NYC. From dinner outings with friends to early morning workouts, her East Coast wardrobe has been noteworthy. Case in point? A pair of unexpected polka-dot capri leggings that the Who What Wear editorial team can't stop talking about. But the look that stopped me in my tracks? Her casual ensemble for her time at the ALO store on Fifth Avenue.
Instead of reaching for classic black leggings, Bieber chose a fresh alternative: light gray leggings. She styled the soft-hued pair with a white graphic tee and matching New Balance sneakers, offering a minimal yet directional take on off-duty dressing.
On Hailey Bieber: New Balance 530 Sneakers ($100); Toteme Belted Naplack Leather Bucket Bag ($1340)
I'm not saying black leggings are out, but if you want to lighten things up, gray offers a compelling alternative. The shade is less stark than white and softer than black, making it the perfect neutral base to pair with, of course, black and white, but also navy, green, and red.
The best part? There’s no shortage of options. Brands like ALO, Lululemon, Sweaty Betty, and more offer elevated gray leggings this season, each channeling the stylish appeal of Hailey’s. With that said, keep scrolling to shop the best gray leggings.
Shop Bieber's Sneakers
Shop the Best Light Gray Leggings
These look the most similar to Bieber's.
Don't overlook Amazon's selection of leggings.
Fitness-loving fashion people always wear ALO's Alosoft leggings because they're flattering and comfortable.
Amazon shoppers love these because they're "as soft as butter."
You may know On for its running sneakers, but its performance leggings are to not be missed.
Who doesn't love pants with pockets?
Another pair of fail-safe Lululemon leggings.
-
It's Here: The It-Girl Skirt Trend to Wear With Kitten Heels This FallBonus points if you wear it in yellow.
-
Hailey Bieber Padded Her Hips for Her Riskiest Red Carpet Look to Date—See the PicsSchiaparelli does it again.
-
I'm a Fashion Editor—These Are the Low-Key Uggs I'll Be Wearing With Leggings All Winter LongI just bought my first pair of Uggs.
-
Elsa Hosk is My Ultimate Fall Style Muse—7 Trends I'm Stealing From HerPlus, where I'm buying them.
-
Sofia Richie Grainge Is Pregnant, and She Shared the News in the SRG Jacket I Know Will Sell Out FirstI give it until November 1.
-
Bella Hadid Just Put a Sexy Spin on the Runway Trend You'll See Everywhere in 2026Leave it to Hadid and Victoria's Secret Creative Director Adam Selman to reimagine a major ready-to-wear runway trend.
-
Sorry, Thongs—Gigi Hadid Just Brought Back This "Dated" Rival at the Victoria's Secret Fashion ShowUnderwear lines and all.
-
All the 2025 Victoria's Secret Fashion Show Runway Looks That Have Our Jaws on the FloorThe night of glamour, wings, and fashion has arrived.
