I Spent 4 Hours on Etsy Finding the 19 Best Vintage Jewelry Picks

What's old is new again. Jewelry trends are cyclical, so what's popular right now probably had a moment in the sun years and years ago too. For instance, chunky gold necklaces were all over the Copenhagen Fashion Week street style scene, and it's far from a new trend. To prove it, I found plenty of amazing vintage options on Etsy, which is my favorite treasure trove for one-of-a-kind pieces.
Etsy also boasts tons of other vintage versions of today's biggest trends. For instance, I recently tapped two L.A. jewelry designers who confirmed that birthstone engagement rings are increasingly popular right now, and you can bet I found pretty vintage options on Etsy. Plus, we received a ton of interest in my story on Prince Harry's ex-girlfriend Cressida Bonas's engagement ring, which is a beautiful example of the "target ring" trend that's all over Etsy. So, without further ado, scroll down to shop my favorite vintage Etsy jewelry from the '20s to the '90s.
Necklaces
Rings
This design is known as a "target ring" and is similar to Prince Harry's ex-girlfriend's engagement ring.
Bracelets
Next, this engagement ring trend is way more popular than you realize.

Erin got her start as a Who What Wear intern in 2011—back when the site only published a single story per day. (We have since increased that number twentyfold.) She graduated magna cum laude from USC and lives in Los Angeles. In college, she also interned at Refinery29, where she was promoted to editorial assistant and then assistant editor. After nearly three years at R29, she came back to WWW in 2015, where she is now the Associate Director of Fashion News. From the Oscars to the Met Gala, she leads the site's entire red carpet coverage strategy. She specializes in celebrity and fashion news but also enjoys writing travel features and runway reports. She frequently contributes to WWW's social accounts and has a sizable following on her personal TikTok.
-
I'm a Fashion Editor on a Budget—27 Incredibly Chic Fall Finds That Will Get You More Bang for Your Buck
Stellar under-$150 finds right this way.
-
You Won't Believe the Vintage Treasures I Just Found on 1stDibs, and No, They're Not All Wildly Expensive
The chicest under-$400 fashion and home décor pieces lie ahead.
-
I'm Getting a Jumpstart on Fall Shopping—33 Affordable Key Pieces You'd Find In a Wealthy Person's Closet
It girl-approved.
-
Enjoy Your End-of-Summer Ice Cream Trips in These 26 Chic Pieces From J.Crew, Nordstrom, and Zara
Keep cool without sacrificing style.
-
My Fashion Friends Put These 30 Exceptionally Good Pieces on My Radar This Month
Good luck picking just one favorite.
-
I'm My Bestie's Stylist—I Sent Her 7 Stylish Outfits From Nordstrom That I Created for Under $350
So rich looking.
-
All of My Friends With Cool Style Are Doing This Ear Piercing Trend That'll Never Become Dated
Stacks on stacks.
-
Capris, Sunglasses, Scarves—Jackie O's Summer Style Has Never Been More Relevant
Peak chic.