We Try Before You Buy: 8 Coat Trends Our Editors Love

Our We Try Before You Buy series aims to take the stress out of shopping and eliminate the number of post office visits you make each month to return failed online orders. We test new-season buys and styling ideas so you don’t have to. Here, we’re letting you know what’s actually worth investing in.
This time of year, the biggest wardrobe decision on most of our minds is Which coat should I buy? As fashion editors, it’s one of the most common questions we get asked as soon as the leaves start to turn. We don’t blame anyone for asking—it can be quite overwhelming. That’s why our latest We Try Before You Buy was an obvious choice. We called in as many coats as we could fit in the fashion cupboard and tried them all on in order to find the best options across this season’s biggest trends for all budgets.
As self-confessed outerwear addicts, this task was hardly a chore, and more than one may have ended up in our online shopping baskets by the end of the day. Amongst our favourites, you’ll find everything from the most talked-about coats (yes, that J.W. Anderson trench does live up to the hype), brand-new styles (Kitri’s recent drop has us all majorly excited) and some unexpected heroes (Mint Velvet’s snake-print trench, anyone?) Keep scrolling to see and shop our editors’ top picks from the biggest coat trends of 2019.
1. The Trench
2. Vinyl
3. Faux-Shearling
4. Animal Print
5. Oversized Tailoring
6. Checks
7. Camel
8. Puffa Jackets
Next: Read about more of the biggest autumn-winter trends here.

Emily Dawes is an editor, stylist and writer with over 12 years in the industry. Known for impeccable taste, our readers trust her advice, especially in her column, expensive-looking high street buys. Working for Who What Wear UK since 2020, Emily has been a contributing editor, branded content editor and affiliate editor. Now, as senior shopping editor, she leads the e-commerce content strategy. After obtaining a BA in English and American Studies from Nottingham University, Emily landed at The Mail on Sunday’s YOU. As the magazine’s fashion editor, she travelled the globe to style and direct fashion editorials and celebrity cover shoots. As a freelancer, she has styled Grazia cover shoots, developed brand marketing and content plans and worked with VIP clients including Elizabeth Day.
-
I Just Saved $1200 By Shopping This Viral COS Sweater Instead of Its Designer Reference
Girl math.
-
My Mom Is in Her 50s and Asked Me for Fashion Advice—8 Chic Nordstrom Outfits I Put Together for Her Under $425
Outdated prints and "ugly" shoes included.
-
Consider This Your Heads-Up: The Coolest People in Fashion Are Already Wearing This New Elegant Outerwear Brand
Founded and designed by celebrity stylist Rob Zangardi.
-
Every Cool Fall Outfit Will Include This Specific Jacket Trend, and I Found the 14 Best Versions
The chicest people in London and New York are wearing it.
-
Case Closed: Women in Paris Just Declared This the Only Coat Trend That Matters
It's so cool.
-
I’m a Senior Shopping Editor—These Are Hands Down the Chicest Coats From October Prime Day
Get ready for endless compliments.
-
A Rich-Looking Closet Is the Vibe—These 30 Amazon Picks Surprisingly Fit the Bill
See the affordable yet chic finds.
-
I’m a Senior Shopping Editor—Here’s Everything I Highly Recommend Buying From the Mango Sale
Get 30% off just about everything